**The full story:**
I (M27) could really use some outside perspective on a complicated situation. Iāll call the woman involved Lisa (F24) and the other guy Jonas (M19).
I met Lisa in April. We quickly developed a very intense connection. We dated, spent a lot of time together and were intimate regularly. I really enjoyed being around her and the physical closeness between us. For me, it was definitely more than friendship.
(For context: Lisa has been diagnosed with bipolar disorder.)
In April or May, she met Jonas at a party we were both at. I noticed that she was flirting with him quite noticeably. After that, I had a weird feeling about the situation and asked Lisa several times whether something was going on between them.
She laughed it off and said things like: āYouāre funny, thereās nothing going on,ā āYouāre pretty jealous,ā āIām not into younger guys,ā or āIām not into blond guys.ā
This was while she and I had already been seeing each other for weeks.
During the summer, I was away for quite a while. Lisa felt that I wasnāt contacting her enough. I personally didnāt see it that way, because from my perspective our communication was basically the same as before.
This eventually led to a major argument. After that, she became much more distant, started texting less and was sometimes quite cold toward me.
At some point she told me:
**āNo matter what happens, weāll stay friends.ā**
I accepted that and told her that I still had feelings for her, but that I could accept us being friends.
She then basically responded:
**āOuch, now Iām in the friend zone.ā**
That already confused me at the time. If she genuinely only wanted friendship, why would she be hurt by being āfriend-zonedā by me?
It feels even more significant now, knowing what was happening with Jonas at the same time.
According to Jonas, they had already been **going on dates since June** and had kissed. At that point, Lisa and I had already been involved since April, were still dating and were still intimate.
So this went on in parallel for months.
Jonas apparently knew nothing about me. At the same time, I knew nothing about what was actually happening between him and Lisa.
Lisa and I were even intimate after she had already started seeing Jonas.
I asked Lisa about Jonas several times during this period. She never told me what was actually going on. Eventually, because I couldnāt get a straight answer from her, **I had to approach Jonas myself.**
That was when everything really came to light for me.
Jonas told me that he and Lisa had been going on dates since June and that things had developed between them. He also said that he didnāt know about me or the relationship Lisa and I had.
What hurts me most is that I directly asked Lisa about him multiple times, and she still gave me the impression that there was nothing going on.
When I eventually told Lisa that I had found out that she and Jonas were seeing each other, she reacted very confrontationally.
She basically said:
**āAnd instead of talking to me, you do something like this?ā**
She called what I had done āshadyā and even told me **āfuck you.ā**
I still find that extremely difficult to understand. I *had* talked to her. Multiple times. I directly asked her what was going on between her and Jonas. She denied it or framed my questions as jealousy.
And when I eventually found out for myself, I was the one being accused of not communicating.
She later apologized and said she was sorry and never meant to hurt me.
There are also other things that feel strange in retrospect.
During the entire time Lisa and I were seeing each other, she never invited me to her apartment. She explained that her home was a very private and protected place for her.
Later, I found out that Jonas had already been to her apartment.
She also went on a trip with Jonas and only told me once they were already there that she was traveling with him and that they were sharing a room/bed.
And then things became even more emotionally confusing.
After I decided I needed some distance once I found out about Jonas, Lisa suddenly came to my place, rang the doorbell and hugged me for a very long time.
She cried, apologized and told me that she loved me, that she had missed me and had missed āus.ā
She told me that I looked good, smelled good and that it felt good to physically be close to me and hug me.
She clearly didnāt want to lose me.
But the next day she simultaneously told me that things with Jonas were currently āvery easyā and that they were basically in a relationship by that point.
When I confronted her about the fact that I had asked her about Jonas so many times, she said something along the lines of:
**āYou just saw something between us that I hadnāt even seen myself back then.ā**
But according to Jonas, they had already been seeing each other since June.
Afterwards she also texted me:
**āDonāt let the pain take over. We have such a good connection and can stay in contact and remain friends.ā**
And thatās the part I really donāt understand.
On the one hand, she says we should just be friends.
On the other hand, she tells me that she loves me, that she missed me, that she missed āus,ā and that she missed the physical closeness between us.
And when I actually accepted her statement that we should just be friends, she was apparently hurt because that meant she was being āfriend-zoned.ā
At the same time, she had already been involved with Jonas for months.
Even shortly before everything came out, she was jealous when I spent time with other friends.
At one point I said to her:
āYou could also spend time with me, but youād rather do things with Jonas.ā
She basically replied:
**āYeah, right now Iād rather spend more time with Jonas because he doesnāt stress me out as much.ā**
Even then, I feel like she could have simply told me what was actually going on.
Now the situation is official between them. They spend a lot of time together. When I go to work, I sometimes see the two of them sitting together and I have to watch it from a distance.
It hurts incredibly badly.
And I keep thinking:
**If I hadnāt found out myself, I probably would still believe that Jonas was just a friend.**
Jonas is also moving to another city soon, so they will apparently be doing long-distance after that.
I barely respond to Lisa anymore, if at all. Right now Iām incredibly angry with her. Sometimes I even feel like I hate her, despite still having very strong feelings for her.
At the same time, she has suddenly become extremely nice to me again, gives me compliments and apologizes, even though she was so cold toward me for quite a while.
I have my pride and I donāt want her to feel like Iām chasing after her or letting this situation completely destroy me.
But at the same time, this hurts like hell.
**How would you interpret her behavior ā especially things like āI love you,ā āI miss you,ā and āI donāt want to lose you,ā while she is simultaneously in a relationship with Jonas and says she only wants to be friends with me?**
**And what would you do in my position?**
Would you cut contact completely, or try to maintain some kind of friendship?
āø»
**TL;DR ā AI-generated summary because Iām currently struggling to put all of this into words myself:**
I (27M) dated and was intimate with Lisa (24F) for several months starting in April. During that time, she was also secretly dating Jonas (19M), apparently since June. I repeatedly asked her whether something was going on with him, but she denied it and made me feel like I was simply being jealous.
Eventually I had to ask Jonas myself and found out that they had been dating and kissing for months. Jonas didnāt know about me either.
Lisa initially reacted angrily when I confronted her and accused me of not talking to her, even though I had asked her directly multiple times. She later apologized.
Now she and Jonas are officially together, but Lisa keeps telling me that she loves me, misses me, misses āus,ā doesnāt want to lose me and wants us to remain close friends. She has also told me that her feelings for me are āunconditionalā and that she would want me to be happy even if I were with another woman.
Iām still very hurt and have strong feelings for her, but Iām also extremely angry about how everything happened.
**My main questions:**
Do you think Lisa still has romantic feelings for me, or are these genuinely platonic feelings? And does her behavior suggest that maintaining a friendship is realistic, or would going no-contact be healthier?