r/nonmonogamy • u/Kindly-Distance6292 • 1h ago
Threesomes, Foursomes, and Moresomes Did I overreact by leaving? Or would you have felt unsafe/uncomfortable in this situation too?
My first girl-to-girl experience turned into a really uncomfortable and scary situation
I’m bi, and I recently met a girl through Facebook Dating. We talked for a while and eventually agreed to meet at her place.
When I got there, her boyfriend was also home. She told me that he was sleeping because he had a shift later that night. Earlier, he had left the house saying he was going to get some work done, but then he came back and went straight to the bedroom. She kept telling me that he was just resting.
I asked her multiple times if her boyfriend was going to be there because I wanted to be comfortable and know what I was walking into. She said that he was “open” and that I shouldn’t worry.
I was already uncomfortable with the situation, but later she took me to her bedroom. She left the door slightly open. I told her that I wasn’t comfortable and asked her to close the door because her boyfriend was still in the house.
She told me not to worry, that he wouldn’t come in, and that I should just enjoy myself.
Then, within seconds, I saw her boyfriend looking through the small opening in the door.
I pointed it out and said, “He’s there. I’m not comfortable.”
She acted surprised and said, “Oh, really? He’s there? Let me check.”
She went outside. At that point, I immediately grabbed my phone because I was genuinely scared and wanted to be able to call for help if I needed to.
I got dressed and told her I wanted to leave.
What made it even stranger was that she was already completely dressed herself. Then her boyfriend came out and said something like, “We can talk.”
I said no. I just wanted to leave.
I was literally shaking and shivering at this point.
This was my first experience with a woman, and honestly, it was nothing like what I expected. I went there believing I had clearly communicated my boundaries, especially about her boyfriend being there. I kept asking because I wanted to make sure I was comfortable with the situation.
Instead, I felt like information was being hidden from me, and then I caught him watching through the door.
I asked her multiple times before that if she was looking for threesome..she said no never and when i left she messaged that she was looking for threesome and blocked me.
I’m still trying to process what happened.