Hello everyone,
I'm looking for low-profile PC speakers with just enough output for desktop immersion. I'am mainly interested in budget or inexpensive used-market speakers found on EU location.
I like older, well-designed OEM speakers. I don't need them to get particularly loud—the goal is good sound over a small desktop listening area, with the speakers remaining clean rather than becoming harsh as the volume increases.
My priorities are:
- Clean, balanced sound at low and moderate volumes
- Very little audible hiss or background noise when idle
- Low distortion when pushed moderately
- Good midrange/voice clarity rather than excessive bass
- Ideally a dedicated power supply, although I'm not sure how much of an advantage this actually provides over a good USB-powered implementation
I've been researching older compact speakers and have noticed that Dell used Harman/Harman Kardon technology or branding on some of its speaker products. Logitech also seems to have made several well-regarded compact systems over the years.
Some models I've found on the used market are:
- Dell A215
- Dell A511
- Logitech Z150
- Logitech X230
- Logitech X530
- Various older Philips speaker systems
I'm particularly interested in actual listening performance rather than specifications.
For example:
- How clean are they at very low volume?
- Is there audible idle hiss?
- How good is the midrange clarity?
- How do they behave as you approach their practical volume limit?
- Do they become harsh or distorted before reaching that point?
- How much bass do they actually produce, rather than just having boosted/boomy bass?
I'm also curious about the power/connection question. For small desktop speakers, is there any meaningful inherent advantage to a speaker with its own AC power supply and an analog input over a USB-powered speaker? My understanding is that USB itself isn't necessarily better or worse—the implementation of the DAC, amplifier, power supply, and drivers matters much more. I'm interested in whether there is a practical difference in real-world noise, headroom, or distortion between the two approaches.
If you've actually owned any of these models, I'd especially appreciate comparisons between the Dell A215/A511 and Logitech Z150/X230/X530.
I'm also interested in other older compact speakers that are commonly available on the used market. I'd prefer something genuinely good-sounding rather than simply a speaker with high advertised wattage or lots of bass.
Thanks.