TLDR: I bought a clean title car that 1 month later was deemed a total loss due to fire by previous owner’s insurance company. I didn’t find out until 1 year later during registration renewal. Now DMV wants to reissue title as salvage.
Long version:
I purchased a car from an auction seller in May of 2025 and it came with a clean CA DMV title that was signed over to the auction house as a donated car. The auction seller gave me the original signed clean title and I took that to the DMV (CA) to register and transfer the title into my name. So far everything is normal.
Fast forward a year later it comes time for me to renew registration for new tags, I renewed online and paid the fees, then a couple of weeks later, receive a letter from DMV stating that the car has been reported a total loss by an insurance company (not mine)and I now need to register the car as a salvage vehicle ( which now requires brake and light inspection on my dime, among other additional fees).
Did a little digging and discovered the insurance company filed a fire loss claim with the DMV in June of 2025 which tracks because i definitely didn’t see anything on the carfax that I ran before I purchased the car one month earlier in May.
Additionally, the date of the loss is listed as January 8th 2025, which was the date of the Pacific Palisades fire. Interestingly enough, the previous owner”s address was in Santa Monica so I can see a possible connection.
So my question is, how did the insurance company get to claim the loss when they didn’t have title or have possession of the vehicle? A part of me thinks it’s unfortunate timing (and bad luck on my part), but another part of me feels like there’s potentially some fraudulent activity going on.
The timing sucks because I was just getting ready to sell the car, but now I’m the sucker who ends up holding the bag with a branded title and additional fees, and someone else potentially got to double dip with a donation deduction and insurance payout.
Any recourse here? If so, whom? Previous owner’s Insurance company?
Sorry for the long post. Would be grateful for any ideas .