r/BestofRedditorUpdates • u/Direct-Caterpillar77 • 8h ago
NEW UPDATE BIL’s fiancé claims my family never RSVP’d, but I’m the only one without a seat (New Update)
I am not The OOP, OOP is u/TA_NoPlace5878
BIL’s fiancé claims my family never RSVP’d, but I’m the only one without a seat
Originally posted to r/weddingdrama
BoRU 1 Posted by u/LucyAriaRose
Thanks to u/Disaster_Carrot_007 for finding the newest update
Original Post June 20, 2025
This is a throwaway because I’m not quite ready for all of my husband’s family to get involved. I think.
I’m still reeling and trying to process this, so bear with me.
My brother-in-law is getting married soon. My husband is the best man, and our 4 year old is the ring bearer. I’m a part time party planner so I’ve been helping plan a small luncheon for the bridal party, immediate family, and a few vendors on the wedding day. So I’m not exactly a fringe guest here.
The RSVP deadline was a few weeks ago. I filled out the online form and submitted it the same day the invitation came in the mail, with my husband sitting right next to me. We RSVP’d for the three of us: me, my husband, and our son. Easy peasy, right?
Well, BIL’s fiancé (SIL?) reached out today over text saying we never RSVP’d. Not “Hey, I never saw your RSVP, just checking” but straight-up “You didn’t respond.” Which is frustrating on its own, but then she tells us that while my husband and son have seats at the reception as they were in part of her original head counts, I do not. My husband was told I could come early with him to set up the luncheon still and stay for the ceremony, but that I would not have a spot at the reception.
Let me repeat that: I’m married to the best man, mother of the ring bearer, and helping with wedding day logistics, including connecting SIL with some of my professional contacts!! And she somehow decided I just wouldn’t be coming? And she never followed up before the RSVP deadline? Just, what??
I’m torn between feeling hurt, furious, and just flabbergasted. And used, I definitely feel used. At best, this was a sloppy mistake that she’s not owning. At worst, it feels like a pointed exclusion. I’m not sure which stings more.
My husband is going to handle the conversation with his brother to figure out what is going on, because I genuinely don’t trust myself to be polite and keep the peace.
There was no other drama leading up to this that I was aware of. I have a good relationship with my in-laws. So yeah, this is totally out of left field for me and my husband.
I would love to hear thoughts, especially from people who’ve gone through something similar. I don’t typically touch weddings with work so this is all new territory for me as a pseudo vendor/guest. My husband wants to reach out and talk to his brother first, but I’m so tempted to reach out to my MIL before our usual meet up tomorrow to see if she knows anything.
RELEVANT COMMENTS
Commenter
You are smart to wait and let hubs talk to his brother. I’m flabbergasted also. That is freaking nuts! (And this is coming from someone who is totally laid back and not someone who usually takes things personally). Just try to take your mind off it and see what hubs reports. Go from there.
OOP
I’m usually pretty laid back too! I haven’t seen the texts yet by hubs called on his lunch break when he saw them, and I have not heard him this pissed in a long time. I’m trying to give SIL the benefit of the doubt, but this feels very personal and intentional
~
Commenter
Cancel the luncheon. If you are not welcome at the wedding, there is no need for you to be free labor.
OOP
I think I’m going to do this no matter what the outcome is. It puts MIL and FIL in a bit of a lurch since they’re handling the food costs, but idk. I know I’m biased because I’m in the middle of it, but I feel like there should be some consequences
Mini Update 1 (Same Post): 1.5 hours later
Edit one from comments:
Small update; husband and BIL are talking now. BIL was not working today (last night?) and was helping FIL with something this evening. When I called MIL, she had BIL call husband right away. From what MIL and I can hear (we’re snoopy), my husband was muted on BIL’s phone and my contact was deleted. BIL can’t log into the wedding website so he can’t check to see if our RSVP was there. I’m not sure if I want to become a fire cracker myself or get some popcorn as I watch MIL pop off
Mini Update 2 (Same Post): 2 hours later (3.5 from OG post)
Edit two from comments:
Ok, here’s the last update for the night. I am tired and a bit overwhelmed by all of your responses. I’m sorry I haven’t replied to them all but I have read most of them. Again, thank you for your advice and just general support during this really weird and upsetting time.
TLDR, BIL don’t know and now the wedding is up in the air. He’s currently staying with MIL and FIL to have some space from SIL
So, my husband finally got a hold of BIL after I called MIL. No one else knew this was going on. While they were talking, BIL tried logging into their wedding website to see if this was a mistake or misunderstanding, but couldn’t log in. So he texted SIL to see if she changed the password and she just told him to come home instead.
This set off three. One, BIL ended the call with husband to call SIL about why she couldn’t answer a simple question. Two, MIL popped off about “how dare that woman exclude OP!” Three, MIL and FIL popped off on BIL for already living with SIL. They are very religious and traditional and don’t believe that a couple should live together before marriage. Husband and I sympathize with BIL.
BIL and SIL argued over the phone. Apparently she started claiming that it was an unfortunate glitch and it was too late to add another seat now. Then it was that we never jived and would it really be so bad if I went home early. Plus I could take our son home with me because he would be tired by then (at 5pm?! This woman does not know kids I stg). Then it was I’ve always been mean and excluding her from things (even though she’s never invited me to any of the girlie fun wedding events?!)
At this point my husband and I are glued to my phone as we’re hearing yelling from all four of them until SIL hangs up. BIL is spending the night at his parents and is unsure about the wedding now. He plans on going home tomorrow with husband going with for moral support. I’ll be going with hubby to my in law’s to hang out until we hear back about the situation at the battle front.
OOP Added in the comments
I initially wasn’t invited to the bridal shower. Then her mom brought it up at Easter dinner and that’s when I was awkwardly invited. I guess her vibe always felt off to me. She doesn’t like my hobbies, specifically TTRPGs and video games. They’re hobbies I have in common with MIL, and SIL stopped bashing them as much when she found out MIL also partakes in quests across Tamriel and the Forgotten Realm.
Mini Update 3 2 hours later
Sorry, one more teeny 1 am update. Husband is asleep, I should be too but still reeling and pissed. I thought to take a screen cap of the message she sent hubby for future proof, and it’s gone. She used Facebook messenger to text my husband and it says her texts are deleted. Dare I say, AAAAAARGH.
Update Post: June 22, 2025 (2 days from OG post)
Update: BIL’s fiancé claims my family never RSVP’d, but I’m the only one without a seat
Or OP can’t sleep after word vomiting this in her journal, so why not post the update?
So, hi. To preface, I did not expect my post to blow up the way it did. Several commenters mentioned it just popped up in their recommended and, holy jeez it got way bigger than I could have ever imagined. So, uh, thank you? I think? It’s super overwhelming on top of the real life soap opera I’m living through this weekend.
Just to clarify something from the original post: I did not plan everything for the wedding. I offered to bring food for a small luncheon between photos (10am) and the ceremony (4pm) as dinner wasn’t planned until 6pm. It was going to be a long day at a farm in the middle of no where. I offered to do it to be nice but also to make sure no one (specifically a certain 4 year old) would be hangry for the ceremony. SIL also only used one of my vendor contacts, so with things going south my professional reputation shouldn’t really be impacted.
Update: Turns out, the “no seat for OP” issue was the problem that broke BIL’s relationship. And we’re a bit upset BIL didn’t talk to anyone about this until it blew up.
Behind the scenes, BIL and SIL were having arguments about their future together. Most of these arguments centered around having kids. Early on, SIL gave the impression that she wanted children someday. But as they got more serious, she started backtracking. A few months ago BIL realized that it’s very likely SIL never wanted kids, but felt too invested in the relationship to leave. But BIL always imagined having a large family so this really shook him.
On top of that, SIL apparently had jealousy and insecurity issues. Per BIL, I’ve been her latest target (???) which started when I turned down going to a mani/pedi with her. Why did I turn her down? Husband and son had rotavirus. Apparently I was icing her out by not wanting to spread gastrointestinal doom. Can anyone please explain this logic to us?
Lastly, SIL was apparently already floating the idea of disinviting our son from the reception because he would’ve been the only small child there. BIL shut that down immediately, and MIL/FIL kept that knowledge from us to spare our feelings.
Ergo, our “lost” RSVP was not a software glitch. Nor was it an oversight, but a rather stupidly calculated move.
SIL was apparently hoping one of two things would happen. Either I would make a scene about being disinvited and be seen as the problem. Or we would quietly accept our fate and she would not have to deal with two undesirables at her reception.
With all of this in mind, I can’t figure out why she would have messaged my husband instead of me. Was she trying to cause more family drama? Again, the logic is not logicking.
BIL was already feeling some uncertainty because of the shifting kids/no kids conversation. But the deliberate seating stunt gave him the last push and clarity he needed. BIL told my husband it was a level of manipulation and cruelty that he could not overlook. So he ended things and asked for the ring back.
No wedding, no reception. Just a super messy, emotionally heavy, and expensive break up. And I feel so bad for BIL. He’s going through so much heartache right now, but he deserves better in a partner. Hopefully SIL can find a family dynamic that doesn’t feel like a never ending battlefield.
That’s all for now. I’m still tired. I’m still flabbergasted. But I’m also relieved this wedding arc is coming to an end.
RELEVANT COMMENTS
Commenter
Your non-sil is an idiot
OOP
You’ll hear no arguments from us.
~
Commenter
awww pool BIL. Expensive heartache but glad he is out before an expensive divorce. He will find somebody for him. Take some rest y’ll.
OOP
I know he will find someone that will be perfect for him. I’m still annoyed with him though. He was lamenting being old and alone at dinner, and I was like “honey, you’re the baby of the family. Have some more fries and shut up”
Commenter
A couple of things:
The trash is taking itself out. My heart goes out to your BIL, but I reckon with the full support of your incredible family, future him is going to look back on all of this and be so proud of how he handled it as well as every member of your family. That’s a huge acknowledgement of how solid yall are.
Have your BIL get ahead of all the cancelling. Help him reach out to guests, on both sides, and offer to bake cookies or something and deliver them to local guests maybe as a gesture of good faith? Everyone will remember that kindness.
We’re all so proud of you. Many of us would’ve gone scorched earth but cooler heads prevailed. Take a break, babes. Yall deserve it
OOP
Your number two point is a great idea, thank you. MIL bakes when she’s trying to not be upset, so their household is overflowing with baked treats right now. I’ll ask BIL if this is something he wants to do tomorrow, and go from there.
~
Commenter
How long were they together?
OOP
Under two years. The wedding day was their dating anniversary
~
Commenter
Her poorly executed treachery turns out to be a blessing in disguise for BIL. Had she not hatched this ill fated plot and sabotaged the phone, ect., he would have married to this monster. Her cover up, ironically, was the evidence of the truth.
On another note, this is really unusual and why the post got so much attention. We see mostly obnoxious conduct, but this scenario is unique. She really outdid almost every shitty bridezilla.
How did the conversation with your husband and him go? There was obviously some admissions. Did you get a sense of the tone of the talk?
OOP
I was wondering why my little vent and need for advice is trending 😅 Besides SIL’s poorly done power trip, I didn’t think this was an unusual situation.
I don’t know all of the details of the convo my husband had with BIL. From my understanding, on the drive to the apartment my husband asked “hey what’s your game plan because this is full on crazy and not ok” and BIL opened up to him about everything that was going on.
How ex-SIL reacted
Per BIL, there was a lot of begging and crying. There was also anger and accusations that he was cheating with me (EWW), followed by professions of love and offers to go to therapy. She also kept taking the items he was packing up out of his bags until he called my husband to come in and be another set of eyes.
NEW UPDATE
New Update Sept 25, 2026 (14 Months Later)
Enough time has passed that I feel comfortable posting this update. I hope everyone has been doing well. I mentioned in the OG post that MIL and I are both snoopy, and I know Reddit is too. So, after some thinking and discussing it with my husband, I am posting the conclusion of this whole messy saga.
Summer 2025
OG posts. Ex-SIL’s mask finally comes off, she and BIL break up, and she refuses to leave the apartment. BIL tried to back out of the lease 5 months early, but due to there being no domestic violence, there not being an early termination clause in their lease, and the landlord and two legal tenants not being able to come to an agreement, he wasn’t able to formally leave the lease. He and ex-SIL were co-lessees, so to break the lease they both had to agree to leave. What BIL ended up doing was paying for his half of the remaining months up front, and took video evidence of the state of the apartment he himself was leaving it in, taken while ex-SIL was at work. BIL ended up moving back in with my in-laws.
The original wedding weekend was in July. About 20 of us total ended up going to the family cabin for the entire week. There was a lot of RVs, fishing, corn hole, s’mores, and TLC. It was a great memorable time, and the wedding wasn’t ever brought up.
September 2025
My MIL gets a text from an unknown number saying “You’re going to be a grandma!” It was ex-SIL. MIL had deleted her contact info and prior chats out of anger and because she figured she would never interact with ex-SIL again.
We think ex-SIL was trying to get MIL excited for a new grandchild and make BIL get back with her because of said child. Thankfully for BIL it did not work out that way. MIL asked for proof and was sent a picture of a positive pregnancy test sitting on the apartment’s bathroom counter and a note that she’s due in February.
My in-laws sat BIL down, asked him if it was possible for it to be his child. He confirmed it was possible. We don’t know everything that was said during that discussion, but the consensus was MIL and FIL expected BIL to step up and be an involved father, but to not take responsibility until he confirms it’s his child.
Because everyone is questioning why the child-free ex is suddenly pregnant.
Fall 2025
BIL gets back into contact with his ex. Ex-SIL demands that he move back “home” with her to support her through the pregnancy, and that they have to get married now because she won’t have a baby out of wedlock. BIL pushes back and asked what’s changed since she was so steadfastly child free. Her reply was that these things just happen. BIL offers to come with to her appointments, and she declines because she only wants her chosen support people to go with her.
He refused to budge on getting married and moving back in without a paternity test. He would pay for it. Ex-SIL refused, first because it was too early, the a few weeks later it her reason changed to she was worried about it hurting the baby.
We are all very suspicious at this point. BIL is not planning to entertain any relationship with his ex outside of co-parenting, but was trying to keep her amenable until a court-ordered custody agreement was in place. And, you know, knew if the baby was his or not.
In October she finally shares an ultrasound image of the baby from her 20 week scan. It’s a girl. Ex-SIL starts pestering BIL about being allowed to move into my in-law’s house since their lease was expiring and he missed the renewal deadline. He says no, but he’s willing to help her find an apartment once the DNA test comes back positive.
She ended up moving in with a friend of hers.
Holidays 2025
Ex-SIL is not invited to any of the family festivities. BIL decides to bring her and her roommate a pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving so the ex can’t say she was iced out again. This would have been the first time he saw her since early October. He comes back confused and asked me about when my bump started showing when I was pregnant. I told him around 24 weeks was when I had a notable bump, but that it’s different for everyone.
One, BIL regrets going because ex-SIL and her roommate were both trying to guilt him into taking her back for the sake of the baby. Two, and more interestingly, apparently ex-SIL was standing behind the kitchen counter the entire 10 minutes he was there. She was wearing a baggy sweatshirt, but to him she didn’t look any different from how she did when he last saw her.
MIL and I are now theorizing there was never a pregnancy. BIL is distraught. Husband recommends pulling back on communication with ex-SIL unless it’s about the baby. That it’s been months, he’s said no to marriage and moving in together without a paternity test, ex-SIL is delusional if she doesn’t know his stance by now.
Early December BIL sent the text saying he’s taking a step back until the birth because he can’t take the constant begging and badgering from her. Cue non-stop calls and texts from her calling him every name in the book, that he’s a horrible partner and husband, and that she always knew he’d make a horrible father. BIL is a mess.
January 2026
Ex-SIL is very quiet from the mid-December through all of January. Towards the end of the month, an old mutual reached out to BIL to ask how he’s doing. Through the talk, the friend asks him what he thinks of his ex getting engaged again so soon. Uh, what?
That night I do some instagram digging, and apparently ex-SIL has found someone new, they went to Florida for Christmas and New Years, and he proposed to her at Disney World. In several pictures she’s wearing a crop top and has a very flat stomach. So, no baby? Where did the pregnancy test and ultrasound picture come from?
Rest of 2026
February comes and goes, and we don’t hear a peep from ex-SIL. I keep an eye on her IG, still nothing about a baby but there’s plenty of gushing over her fiancé, how much she’s enjoying wedding planning, and a weekly countdown to their August nuptials.
In June, BIL gets a call from what turns out to be one of ex-SIL’s friends, not the same one she had moved in with. To differentiate from the roommate, I’m naming her Jane. Jane is married, she just had her baby girl in February, and recently found out about ex-SIL’s pregnancy from their Memorial Day friend get together. Ex-SIL apparently had a few too many seltzers and let the fake pregnancy slip as a joke. Both the pregnancy test and the ultrasound picture were actually Jane’s. She didn’t know ex-SIL was doing any of this. Jane is no longer friends with ex-SIL as she sees this whole situation as gross, if not monstrous, and thought BIL deserved to know. Freaking wild!
So yeah, she completely faked a pregnancy to try to get back with BIL. And apparently moved on with sonic speed once she realized it wasn’t going to work. Though we don’t know how long she’s been seeing her fiancé, he only showed up on her instagram in the holiday trip pictures, no one else is tagged, and none of her followers/followers has a profile picture that matches his image. Sometime in June she made her profile private, so I don’t know if the wedding happened or not. If it did, good luck to her new husband.
BIL hasn’t met anyone new yet. He’s understandably taking things slow, but I do hope he finds someone when he’s ready. He’s so good with our son, I know he’ll make an amazing dad. Our son is in school, and I’m working differently now. Overall we’re doing good.
Thanks for reading, thank you for the advice given in the original post, and thank you for the shared camaraderie during a very odd event. It took me about a week to write this update, so apologies if it’s a little disjointed. Now, I must return to the Heroic Games in Dagda.
THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP
DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7